A Lifetime ACC Fan’s Perspective on ACC Officiating

It’s a sad thing : the ACC apparently doesn’t even realize that it is killing its own brand.  The ACC is a basketball conference first and foremost, and despite expansions designed to enhance football, the heart and the soul of the nearly seventy year old league is hoops.  And the ACC is killing hoops, little by little by destroying rivalries with scheduling and…dare I say it…its referees.  Increasingly it is obvious to all but fans wearing blue-tinted glasses that they aren’t going to get a fair shake from the zebras in charge of the games.

This is not wholly an NC State perspective.  As a Clemson fan recently told me shortly after Karl Hess unceremoniously asked two distinguished former Wolfpack players to leave the arena earlier this year that he was not surprised.  “I hate seeing him come out on the floorl anytime Duke or Carolina is in town.  That’s when we all know it’s us against them.”  And by them, he meant Karl Hess: “he’s never seen a Tar Heel or a Blue Devil do anything wrong when the chips are down.”

Similar comments have been echoed by Maryland, Virginia and Georgia Tech fans.  “Is he (Hess) on the Mike Krzyzewski Show up there?” he asked.  “Might as well be if he isn’t.”

Anyone forty or older can remember an ACC where anything could happen and probably would…no game was one to be taken for granted, and it didn’t matter if an undefeated first place team was playing on the road with a team in dead-last, they were at major risk of getting upset.  And it happened, too.

One of the hallmarks of the old ACC were the officials: they were often as big a celebrity as were the coaches or players, and most knowledgeable ACC fans could name them on sight.

Take Lou Bello, for example.  “Lou was all referee and part clown,” “Bones” McKinney, Wake Forest University’s basketball coach from 1958 to 1965, said about Bello. “He had as good a judgment as anybody refereeing during my time. When I saw him walk out on the court, I was not concerned. I knew I would get as good a shake as anybody.”  Bello would make the tough call and take the heat for it, and actually seemed to revel in doing it…and as often as not, that call would go against a powerful ACC team jockeying to be in position to make a run at the national championship.

Bello told me once that he tried his best to be “color-blind” when it came to uniforms, and that he saw players, and not the school’s name on the front of the jersey.  That was during a short run as a sports anchor on television here in the Triangle, one that brought Bello to my school to talk to us about his time on the hardwoods. Most people loved Lou Bello, he was funny, he was memorable and most importantly, he was fair.  “If he thought he hurt {a coach with a missed call}, it would hurt him afterward,” McKinney said in the former referee’s obituary. Coming from a coach, that’s high praise — and Lou Bello deserved it.

There are other referee’s names in the lore of the ACC, Lenny Wirtz, who it is said in jest that Dean Smith would have sent to the gallows if he could have, and too many others to mention.  Fans will often remember those old school referees as “the worst of the worst,” mainly because they would unflinchingly make a call when one was deserved.  That fans of all of the schools in the original ACC remember them pretty much the same way serves as testament to their integrity.  Games were decided by the players, and that helped to make the ACC the best basketball circus on the planet, NBA included.

Now, not so much.  The regular season has largely lost its luster and quite frankly, any ACC game is no longer referees have their mind made up towards giving the Blues all the breaks and just when they look like they are on the ropes, anything questionable on the team looking to upset them is going to be called.  That’s not just State, it’s Clemson.  It’s FSU.  It’s UMD.  And so forth.
Sure, Dean Smith, Lefty Driesell, Bones McKinney, Norm Sloan and other well-established coaches would work over the officials, and a Lefty temper tantrum was a thing of beauty…but the games were called a lot more fairly and without apparent bias.  Nowadays, tales like this are all too common:

So, is it true? Does Duke really get all the calls?’ ” former Duke player Andre Sweet mimics. “I’m like, ‘Of course, it’s true. It’s Duke.’ It’s Mike Krzyzewski. The refs were afraid of him. He could get you calls that no one else could get. That’s part of playing for Duke.”

One has wonder what an old-school ACC referee like Lou Bello would have made of that.  It wasn’t that Bello didn’t have to deal with strong personalities, after all, Bones McKinney once installed a seat belt on his part of the Wake Forest bench in order to cut down on the number of technical fouls he received. Norm Sloan and Left Driesell could melt someone’s hair with their temper.  And Dean Smith would yap non-stop at the heels of a referee as they went by.

And presumably, he did so without telling a coach to “shut the #$% up” when a coach inevitably gave him the business for a call the coach didn’t like.  Or by “studying tendencies” of teams.  Or by making proclamations that “UNC doesn’t foul as much” (perhaps after studying tendencies?) No sir, Lou called ’em like he saw them, and he did so with a smile on his face most of the time.

Too bad there aren’t referees like Bello around the league any longer, because the ACC is less for it. StatefansNation has shown a statistical discrepancy between the Royal Blues and the rest of the conference, national columnists have recently called ACC referees into question with crucial calls or non-calls, and the league has said nothing in public in reply.  Perhaps they don’t need to: their silence says more than any rationalization that John Cloughtery — a former official himself — can ever offer. That silence says: sit down, shut up and take your medicine.

Too bad that medicine is helping to kill the best sports league around.  No one likes playing poker against a stacked deck, and even the perception of such a thing can sour the taste in any fan’s mouth.  That’s a perception that is becoming an apparent reality not to just ACC fans but also to objective national commentators and it is leaving heads shaking everywhere.

ACC College Basketball

41 Responses to A Lifetime ACC Fan’s Perspective on ACC Officiating

  1. bill.onthebeach 03/20/2012 at 6:43 PM #

    “Anyone forty or older can remember an ACC where anything could happen and probably would…no game was one to be taken for granted, and it didn’t matter if an undefeated first place team was playing on the road with a team in dead-last, they were at major risk of getting upset. And it happened, too.”

    Yes, I do….

    and ^^oceanman.. +1 on Hank Nichols…..

    Now… as to the quote… I think we will see those days again in the near future… once the great transition (Roy and Rat retired plus ‘Cuse and Pitt) is complete.

    As to officiating… can’t play with ’em and can’t play without ’em… that’s part of the game too.

    In the meantime… it’s a he!!alotofun ragging on ’em…. and it is worth noting… no matter where you stop in ACC, including Orange County CC, everybody says the same thing, just from the other direction.

  2. ancsu87 03/20/2012 at 6:47 PM #

    Agree with you Bill. Also Hank Nichols was one of the best! Even as an 8 year old kid when I heard his name I knew it would be a fair called game.

  3. PackMan 03/20/2012 at 7:00 PM #

    I love this blog and the fans that comment on it – but can we PLEASE move past this topic, at least for now? I rarely post anything, but read almost everything and lately I feel that every other time I check the site there is another article on the unfair officiating.

    Can we at least agree to drop this until the season is over? I can think of one or two more exciting things happening now that are worth discussion.

    I get it- I’m a graduate and a life-long fan. One of my earliest memories is watching the ’83 championship on TV with my Dad. I lived in Owen Hall on campus and walked to games in Reynolds Coliseum. I was even tossed from a game for getting a little too out-of-hand. (one of my proudest moments in life).

    I get the analysis and agree with the conclusions- but at a certain point (and I feel like we’re there) it’s just not fun to talk about anymore. Everyone gets it.

    Now let’s go kick ass on Friday.

  4. 61Packer 03/20/2012 at 7:16 PM #

    Kick Kansass.

  5. tuckerdorm1983 03/20/2012 at 7:59 PM #

    I don’t buy all this BS about the refs. I bet if you checked to see who the refs in the ACC pull for when they are not refereeing you would most likely find it to be the blues. I don’t care. We just have to be clearly better than any team in the ACC, especially the blues, and then it does not matter what the ref does. Beat them by 20 points and the ref can’t swallow his whistle at the end of the game and let “his” team win.

  6. rlgray 03/20/2012 at 8:02 PM #

    I mentioned before we have the Dean Smiith Rule (aka the 35 second clock) to stop the four corners. Then came the Jimmy V Rule (aka the Double Bonus Rule – shot 2 after 10 fouls rather than 1 & 1) to stop teams taking advantage of poor fouls shooting by the opponent to gain too much of an advantage (you need to have seen the 1983 NCAAT for this). Now we need a Swofford Rule – no grad or former AD of a conference school can be ACC Commissioner (to avoid even the appearance of bias).

  7. tvopack 03/20/2012 at 8:21 PM #

    PackMan, I’m completely agreeing with you.

  8. highstick 03/20/2012 at 9:15 PM #

    Good one, Alpha…As another who remembers Lou “turning cartwheels” and other strange things on the court, you got it right.

    Since I’m out of town working for a few days, I picked up the USA Today copy last night in the hotel. There was an article about officiating and quotes by Charles Barkley gripping about the officials calling the “lane violation” in the game this weekend.

    Part of our problem and it’s the “whole danged attitude” is that no one wants to call the game by the rulebook. Barkley’s “let ’em play is pure BS…Let ’em play means, let those who have not learned the basics and rules of the game run rampant over the other guys who play totally by the rules. It’s almost impossible to play the game by the book and win now cause of that attitude.

    Is Swofford at fault? Absolutely! Is he the only one? Heck, no! Play the game by the rule book and quit the pushing, hooking, flopping, traveling, carrying, foot shuffeling, and all of the other junk that is clearly not within the rules. If the players can’t play, then who gives a crap…

    Years ago, we used to watch the Harlem Globetrotters bend every rule in the book in their games…But remember, that was entertainment, not a game of real competition. Last week, a friend of mine who also goes back to the 50’s and 60’s and I were talking about Goose Tatum and the Globetrotters. He reminded me of a College All Star team that was put together to play the Globetrotters “straight up”. The common thought was the Trotters couldn’t beat ’em…Not so! The Trotters knew the rules and had not forgotten how to play within the rules of the game…They beat those College All Stars!

    I wonder if you could take a Hansborough et al team, make them play by the book and see if they could beat another team with reasonable talent…

    One of the points that I was making in Pride’s article yesterday was that “we…meaning the ACC” earned that automatic Eastern Regional spot back in the 16 team NCAA Championship series. Granted, the team that went to the Eastern Regionals was not necessarily the best team in the league, but was the ACC tourney winner and that in itself, was a very respected position! It’s no wonder we struggle to get 4 teams in the NCAA’s now. It used to be common to see 6 or more…

  9. redwolf87 03/20/2012 at 9:55 PM #

    Refs back in the day would never have dreamed of impugning themselves with initials on the shoes.

    The Karl Hess incident was indeed a turning point. His blatant act, plus the ridiculous events that followed, from the childish protest at the ACC Tournament to the disgraceful performance by Brian Dorsey, have spoken volumes.

    John Clougherty is either totally incompetent or internally complicit. And I don’t care if these refs are “independent contractors”–he’s got to be held responsible. Would not be surprised to see him retire in the offseason.

    We’ll find out just how much the ACC values officiating “performance” next year. I’ll bet money Hess and Dorsey (and Ayers) are again deemed “top-notch” officials and we see them in a fair share of our games.

  10. RaleighBound 03/20/2012 at 10:32 PM #

    Our own administration has subtly called attention to this subject. It is now up to the fanbase (thank you SFN) to keep this issue in the public eye. This is an important issue going forward, and we should not allow the ACC establishment to think they can keep doing dirty business with impunity. Swoff & Clougherty should have been front and center to criticize what happened to NCSU in Durham and Raleigh and the ACC Tourney, not to mention the corrupt hose job in Virginia this year; but, they weren’t. Any questions?

  11. NCSU84 03/20/2012 at 10:37 PM #

    Can someone explain to me the governance model for the ACC? Specifically, who does the commissioner report to and how do we put the pressure on for his resignation or termination?

  12. JohnGalt78 03/20/2012 at 11:36 PM #

    PackMan….I AGREE bud. Let’s get ready to play some GREAT ball Friday night and beat KU. Last week and now this week….well folks, its just so special to go through the day with this sense of pride, excitement, anticipation, hope, etc. I’m walking on air….tapping back into the exact same feelings from those special weeks in ’74 and 83′ (I’m that old). I thank my team for giving us that gift. Damn it feels so freakin good! And even better….the UNCheats are hang dogging around, whimpering, and whining and shit like that. What a contrast. God willing, we will meet them in the regional final….but first things first. What we have here is so very similar to 83. I wish I could impart that to the younger wolves out there. Its a kind of mojo that lifts us up and we become believers…followers….supporters…almost teammates with these special guys. The energy is almost tangible and it can carry us to victory. I’m not predicting anything here. But I recognize this feeling and a swear we are going to find a way to win Friday. I felt it about the G’town game. I feel it stronger now. I see it oozing from this team. Not overconfidence….but true, controlled, comfort in their own skin type confidence. Not cockiness or swagger….but a “knowledge” that no matter the opponent, we have what it takes to beat them. I’ll be surprised if we lose Friday. And again, the next game…..so you know where I’m headed with this. Forget about the refs for now. Just enjoy this time because it is special and rare. I LOVE THE WOLFPACK! I want the pep band to play our fight song at my funeral….but not for a while! GO PACK!!!!!!!!!!!!

  13. JSRy2k 03/21/2012 at 1:01 AM #

    Well said, ryebread. I love the perspective on the blues. On the flip side we know what it’s like to play with foul trouble, and we’ve been a much better team in the NCAAs now that we can play ball without all the tit-tat calls.

  14. howlie 03/21/2012 at 6:43 AM #

    Nicely done, Alpha.

  15. Rick 03/21/2012 at 8:06 AM #

    “I love this blog and the fans that comment on it – but can we PLEASE move past this topic, at least for now?”

    No, we (at least I) will keep this issue in the public eye until it is fixed.
    If you see an article with the word official in it, just do not click on it.

  16. chris92heel 03/23/2012 at 3:14 PM #

    Karl Hess favors the heels? Lawd, I done heard it all now.

Leave a Reply