BJD’s 2010-11 All-ACC Basketball Picks

Despite my (largely successful) startegy of avoiding Wolfpack games, I watched some other ACC games. Enough to bore you all with my personal picks for conference honors. Not bored enough? Here are last year’s selctions. Since my viewing hours declined, I “sanity checked” my gut feelings more than usual. I even accepted a handful of sane nudges. Without further ado:

Player of the Year: Nolan Smith, Duke

In November and early December, Smith wasn’t even his team’s best player. Then Kyrie Irving got hurt – and Nolan Smith proceeded to do anything and everything for the Blue Devils. He’s been the lead dog from the first to the last ACC game, and this isn’t a close call or debateable in any way.

Coach of the Year: Roy Williams, UNC

Coming off a disastrous 2009-10 campaign (in which Roy still beat Sidney Lowe twice), Roy looked lost again early. Vanderbilt and Minnesota thumped the Holes. Early on in ACC, lowly Georgia Tech beat UNC by 20. His team had no front-court depth (thanks to the Wear twins’ departure), and no great scoring options. Then, his starting point guard walked out halfway through the conference season. Naturally, UNC rolled to a 14-2 mark, the only other loss coming at Cameron (despite leading most of the way in a spirited game). That’s no easy feat no matter how down the league was, and to do so with rebounding, defense, and (outside of Atlanta) consistent effort equals COY. Coach K, Steve Donahue, and Tony Bennett all deserve honorable mention.

Rookie of the Year: Kendall Marshall, UNC

Here’s this year’s contrarian pick. Marshall’s teammate, Harrison Barnes, will win this award in a very comfortable vote. But after Roy Williams, Kendall Marshall is unquestionably the man most responsible for UNC’s regular season title. He makes the Heels function, and became the glue that held the team together after Larry Drew II took his ball and went home. Not many freshmen have that kind of mettle, and it’s an honor the kid really deserves.

    First Team All-ACC:

Nolan Smith, Duke
Malcolm Delaney, Virginia Tech
Reggie Jackson, Boston College
Jordan Williams, Maryland
John Henson, UNC

Like last year, the first four are no-brainers, in my view. Jackson barely made the media’s first team, which is patently absurd. Kyle Singler is on the media’s first team (more votes than Jackson), because several sportswriters apparently needed to fill out their ballots 2 or 3 weeks before the season ended. Henson grabs the last spot as an reward for being my defensive player of the year. He’s still an asshole, though.

    Second Team All-ACC:

Kyle Singler, Duke
Demontez Stitt, Clemson
Tyler Zeller, UNC
Kendall Marshall, UNC
Harrison Barnes, UNC

The second team is led by the aforementioned Singler and the ridiculously unheralded Demontez Stitt. Clemson has a first round ACCT bye, and no other player in shouting distance of all-ACC distinction. Following behind are a troika of Holes, all pretty much equally valuable in their own way.

    Third Team All-ACC:

Joe Trapani, Boiston College
Reggie Johnson, Miami
Jeff Allen, Virginia Tech
Derwin Kitchen, Florida State
Iman Shumpert, Georgia Tech

Trapani and Allen had very solid years in supporting roles, playing Robin to Batmen Jackson and Delaney. Reggie Johnson had a very solid year for Miami, despite the Canes’ general suckitude. Speaking of the whole being much greater than the sum of its parts…just look at Florida State. The Noles were more or less the same team after Chris Singleton’s injury (and his numbers weren’t great before that), so I give third team honors to their senior “glue guy.” Everybody said I was crazy not to have Shumpert on the squad, and that he should really be second team. I counter that his numbers are inflated by the 150 or so combined he scored against the matador-defending Demon Deacons, and that every time I watch him play, I think “Ishua Benjamin.” I relented and gave him the final spot ahead of Singleton.

About BJD95

1995 NC State graduate, sufferer of Les and MOC during my entire student tenure. An equal-opportunity objective critic and analyst of Wolfpack sports.

10-11 Basketball ACC ACC Teams Rankings & Lists

8 Responses to BJD’s 2010-11 All-ACC Basketball Picks

  1. Wulfpack 03/07/2011 at 9:35 PM #

    Good stuff. As bad as our year was, it gave me some extra time to watch some fairly decent basketball down the stretch. Nolan Smith and Roy Williams are locks for their awards. I don’t think you can reasonably argue otherwise. I get what you are saying about Marshall, he’s good. But Barnes has the star power and played very well the second half of the season. And great call on Stitt — I never felt like he got the attention he deserved. Would also be interested to see your all freshman team. CJL makes it on talent alone, but it was fairly slim pickens.

  2. redwolf87 03/07/2011 at 9:59 PM #

    Can’t really argue with any of that. Nice job.

  3. BJD95 03/07/2011 at 10:12 PM #

    Ha, I usually don’t do a full “all rookie” team, and this year I would have had a hard time getting past #1 and #2.

  4. Hrryhood 03/07/2011 at 10:15 PM #

    Wow, I’m pretty sure king of the douche bags Mike Gminski had the same two teams yesterday. Helluva work of insight here.

  5. xphoenix87 03/07/2011 at 11:31 PM #

    AS much as I have to grudgingly admire Roy’s work this year, I think Seth Greenberg deserves a lot of credit for what he did with roster devastated by injuries. He’s definitely still got some talent, but basically was working with a 6 player rotation.

    Singler has to go first team over Henson. Henson is a tremendous defensive force, I will absolutely give you that, but he’s a black hole on offense. Singler is a solid defensive player and a matchup nightmare offensively. I don’t care if he had a shooting slump at the end of the year. His body of work was plenty strong, and even when he wasn’t shooting well, he did a good job of getting to the line.

    I know Georgia Tech sucks. I don’t care. Shumpert is a scoring machine. He led his team in points, assists, rebounds and steals, and he’s not an inefficient scorer. That deserves 2nd team.

    I also think you’re overrating Marshall a bit. I actually like Marshall a lot, but I think he got the “replacing Larry Drew” boost. Drew’s awfulness made Marshall look that much better in comparison.

    btw, I’ll take Jerai Grant over Stitt and anyone on the 3rd team except Shumpert. Talk about underrated. Doesn’t get nearly the recognition he deserves as a defensive force and surprisingly effective weapon around the rim.

  6. Tau837 03/08/2011 at 2:26 AM #

    I’d have Shumpert on the first team over Singler (with Smith, Jackson, Delaney, Williams), and I’d have Singleton second team.

    My 1st team:

    Smith
    Williams
    Delaney
    Jackson
    Shumpert

    My 2nd team:

    Singler
    Barnes
    Henson
    Zeller
    Singleton

    My 3rd team:

    Stitt
    Allen
    Johnson
    Marshall
    Trapani

  7. tuckerdorm1983 03/08/2011 at 7:26 AM #

    look, I am a hater. A born in the world, from the first water hater of UNC. I have many UNC friends and I even attended school there for many years after leaving NC state. I have to hide my true feelings from them. I have been to many more games at the Dean “F***K***” Dome than I have at the RBC. Here is what I have to say:

    ROY AND HIS BOYS CAN BITE MY LEFT “TESTICLE”. I HOPE THEY LOSE EVERY GAME FROM HERE UNTIL ETERNITY.

    That is all.

  8. swamppack 03/08/2011 at 8:33 AM #

    OF COURSE, State will end up with nothing AGAIN. We are so….well, you know the word. No, i’m sorry, i’ve got to say it. Irrelevant. There, now I feel so much better.

Leave a Reply