Why search firms are now key to finding a coach

The first rule of Parker Executive Search is that you don’t talk about Parker Executive Search.

Northern Illinois Athletic Director Jim Phillips quickly rattled off his reasons for hiring PES to assist in his search.

“Five things that to me were really important in this search that Dan Parker and his team were able to provide:

1. Needed a highly confidential search.
2. An outstanding candidate pool.
3. Extremely organized.
4. No surprises.
5. Search that was done swiftly but in a very strategic fashion with a great result.

“That was pretty critical for us as we looked at finding a new basketball coach,” Phillips said. “There’s no question it was a buyer’s market in that so many jobs were open; I think nearly 50 have changed over at the Division I level. It’s a very competitive process and unless you have those five components it makes it extremely, extremely challenging. Dan Parker and his staff did just an absolutely incredible job for Northern Illinois University.”

Firms also can cut down on the embarrassment of a search. Arkansas courted a couple of coaches even before Altman, and finally turned to PES to avoid being pilloried in the press any further.

I literally shudder every time I think about Lee Fowler’s quote declaring that if he had to do another BB coaching search that he would still not use a search firm. If time really is money, then using a search firm looks like a good investment to me:

Parker’s firm doesn’t come cheap. Arkansas paid $90,000. Kentucky paid $50,000. The fee typically includes gauging the interest of candidates, providing the school with salary requirements, performing background checks and arranging face-to-face meetings. Parker allows that his firm “generally manages expectations.” He adds that “to date we have not had a public rejection without having an immediate go-to candidate for a client.” He also wrote that searches typically take 7-14 days.

About VaWolf82

Engineer living in Central Va. and senior curmudgeon amongst SFN authors One wife, two kids, one dog, four vehicles on insurance, and four phones on cell plan...looking forward to empty nest status. Graduated 1982

General NCS Basketball

32 Responses to Why search firms are now key to finding a coach

  1. BoKnowsNCS71 05/08/2007 at 12:48 PM #

    Isn’t another good reason the “requirement” or at least the civility between schools to ask first if they can negotiate with their current coach? Is that a rule or just expected. Years ago, a coach would quit and then would announce his new job. Usually the current school was asked if their coach could be interviewed. Not sure “No” would always fly.

    I don’t know if the NCAA regulates this or if it the ADs try to respect their peers but I suspect that once the hiring search gets passed off to a third party then the AD/School can wash his hands of any impropriety in the negotiation process.

    Another possibility is that working coaches might be able to talk more privately with the headhunters. Even if they are secure in their current job for the moment, they could let it be quietly known that they would be willing to consider moving (assuming the offer was good). The down side might be those who just want to use it as a way to up their current salary.

    Seems to me a good headhunter might be able to work both sides of this. For the school and for the coach.

  2. old13 05/08/2007 at 1:12 PM #

    “I literally shudder every time I think about Lee Fowler’s quote declaring that if he had to do another BB coaching search that he would still not use a search firm.”

    Me too! Just another in the long list of reasons why Foulup should be ridden out of town on a rail!

  3. legacyman 05/08/2007 at 1:49 PM #

    If Lee could end up with as good a candidate as Sidney for the next coaching position then methinks your comments would fade away.

  4. old13 05/08/2007 at 2:06 PM #

    ^I give no credit to Foulup for Sidney except to saying “yes” when Sid said “how ’bout me!” after Foulup dragged NCSU through the mud for a month. And to say he’d do it the same way again is ludicrous!

  5. tractor57 05/08/2007 at 2:14 PM #

    The coaching search that ended up with Lowe as the coach is a prime example of why a search firm is useful. The end results were great but the process …

  6. Mr O 05/08/2007 at 2:40 PM #

    It would be interesting to see who we ended up with had a search firm been used in basketball. Would it have been Coach Lowe???

  7. Rick 05/08/2007 at 2:46 PM #

    The basketball search was run as poorly as humanly possible.
    I have no confidence in anything LF does. His main attirbute seems to be the ability to talk alot without saying anything.
    I am not ssure he could find his way to the RBC center if you put him in the middle of Carter Finley.

  8. Sam92 05/08/2007 at 2:56 PM #

    Sid is great.

    we are so lucky, ’cause it sure wasn’t skill that got him here

    Parker’s firm may not be cheap – but corporate executive search firms (i.e., headhunters) are often charging 10-15% of annual salary, so for the really big hires Parker’s not out of line.

  9. RedTerror29 05/08/2007 at 3:20 PM #

    $50,000 for a $1-2 million a year position is peanuts.

  10. redfred2 05/08/2007 at 3:36 PM #

    Does anyone think that the team of Oblinger/Fowler realizes that it’s not about them, or anything they’ve created. Sure they were here, but Sidney Lowe came back, as practically a last resort, and for reasons that are everything a WOLFPACK fan could ever wish for. And TOB came here because he knows this place has enough spirit and enthusiam, along with great facilities, to produce a powerhouse. I don’t know if any planning was underway for the new facilities before the arrival of Fowler or Oblinger, but all of the loyal fan following comes from way back, before Oblinger’s or Fowler’s times. Most of it, along with the new excitement and funding that Chuck Amato (a Les Robinson Hire) generated while he was here, I can’t really credit to any of the current administration.

  11. Rick 05/08/2007 at 3:53 PM #

    I would imagine they are so busy patting themselves on the back they have no time for the introspection required to understand how little they had to do with the hires.

  12. redfred2 05/08/2007 at 3:59 PM #

    You are exactly right about that Rick. They are oblivious benefactors of great fortune.

  13. redfred2 05/08/2007 at 4:03 PM #

    sorry, that should have said “beneficiaries”

  14. packpigskinfan23 05/08/2007 at 4:28 PM #

    With a search firm, we may not have gotten Coach Lowe… which I am REALLY glad we did get him, but Lee Fowlup deserves 0 credit for Sidney Lowe being our coach. I am not in the know about much of this, but it seems to me that Fowlup left Lowe on the backburner for some point after Sid even mentioned the idea of him coming back. Fowlup was still looking for someone else, and settled for Sid. He knew it would make us happy too.

    If Sidney Lowe didnt REALLY want to be our coach, he would have stayed in the NBA. He wanted the job. He wanted it bad enough that he took it knowing he would have to work his ass off and get the Pistons through the playoffs AND work on his degree at the same time. He wanted the job so bad that he did all of that while studying the huge book of rediculous recruiting rules and other NCAA rules. I will never forget what Sidney did to be our coach. Lee Fowler wanted someone(anyone) to fill the spot. He got lucky.

  15. PapaJohn 05/08/2007 at 4:36 PM #

    Hey big chief SFN, what’s the statute of limitations on kicking LF’s butt? Is there a requisite number of posts after which we drop it and move on? By now we must have many hundreds of posts saying exactly the same old thing.

    He stumbled through the BB coach like a clown but ended up with Sid, thank heavens. I think we all like Chuck’s replacement so far. We’ve got fine facilities. It looks like we just signed a contract to improve radio coverage and make more money, and maybe even give us Internet coverage. Things are definately looking up.

    SO OF COURSE WE HATE HIM!!!!

    SFN is the very best place I’ve found yet for current and timely news on the Pack so I keep coming back, but this stuff is getting old.

  16. redfred2 05/08/2007 at 4:51 PM #

    So, PapaJohn, the radio situation is being brought up to date, kind of finally getting in line with what everyone else is doing and up with the times, so to speak. Is that supposedly a huge feather in Lee Fowler’s cap?

    BTW, I wonder how many pictures of Amato there will be in the football programs this season?

  17. TNCSU 05/08/2007 at 4:53 PM #

    PapaJohn, I have to agree — this is worse than beating the dead horse about our old coach’s offense, etc. IT’S VERY OLD.

  18. packpigskinfan23 05/08/2007 at 5:04 PM #

    redfred- I dont know if you can say that getting an FM station to air our games is really getting it up to date… now if we DO get internet coverage, THEN maybe we can talk about being up with the times.

  19. packpigskinfan23 05/08/2007 at 5:06 PM #

    Lee Fowler is the man who runs our athletic dept. He is a moron. He has continually f-ed up. He just signed a new contract. WHY? HOW?

    if SFN dosnt speak up, then who will?! what happens when he screws up 3 or 4 more times and gets another contract?! then can we beat the dead horse?

  20. redfred2 05/08/2007 at 6:14 PM #

    Um, ppsf23, updating to FM programing is a distant memory for most everyone out there these days. But in the year 2007, at NCSU, it’s considered the big time.

  21. packpigskinfan23 05/08/2007 at 6:23 PM #

    we be ballin’ now!!!!

  22. Rick 05/09/2007 at 9:52 AM #

    Papajohn,
    You have mentioned 4 things that LF has done
    1) Hire Lowe – we both agree that search was the epitomy of pathetic
    2) Hire ROB – he hried a search firm, half credit at best for staying out of hte way
    3) Facilities – Lf himself has said the money was raised by the WPC. How is this something good for him? maybe half creedit for not screwing it up
    4) upgrading the radio – Whew, we got to FM 25 years after every other major university. It is not like he jumping the curve and getting us on something extraordinary.

    You do not understand the “hate” (of course I still do not understand how being unhappy wiht someone’s performance is hate). I do not understadn the love. THe man has done nothing but shown contempt for NCSU’s fans. Why would we embrace him?

  23. PapaJohn 05/09/2007 at 12:41 PM #

    Rck – not suggesting you (or anyone) ’embrace him.’ Just suggesting that there are more interesting things to talk about than rehashing over and over again Fowler’s flaws.
    He’s a terrible AD. We all agree. We wish he was gone. We’ll never forgive him for the humiliation he caused during the BB search.
    Let’s move on.

  24. PapaJohn 05/09/2007 at 12:42 PM #

    ^ apologies, should be ‘Rick’

  25. CedarGroveWolf 05/09/2007 at 2:16 PM #

    agree PapaJohn, deadhorse issue.

Leave a Reply