Excessive Celebrations – WTF?!

In today’s world of You Tube and multimedia on the internet…we’d like to ask if anyone has any pictures or footage of the on-field celebrations in which the football teams at the University of Georgia AND Notre Dame participated after scoring late-game touchdowns. We would LOVE to share these celebrations with the world.

We are 100% serious. Did anybody see this?

When both Georgia and Notre Dame scored go ahead touchdowns late in the 4th quarter of their comebacks, both schools partied like it was 1999. With the score tied 13-13 and an extra point still to be kicked to give the Bulldogs a come from behind win over Colorado, the Bulldogs all piled on the touchd0wn scoring receiver in the end zone. Even the quarterback was given the opportunity to run 25+ yards to the back of the end so that he could jump on the pile.

Of course, no penalties were called – unlike the situation when NC State “excessively celebrated” what we thought was the go ahead touchdown against Akron a couple of weeks ago. That penalty significantly contributed to Akron’s great field position and ability to drive the ball for a game winning score.

We are SICK AND TIRED of the ridiculous inconsistency of judgement calls of officials throughout the country on these types of plays. NC State’s excessive swagger and style of play since Coach Amato’s arrival in Raleigh has undoubtedly played a role in a preconceived expectation on the part of officials that the Pack deserves (is expected) to commit these penalties – so, we have to take some blame for this. But, the bias and the inconsistent application of these calls is reaching a point of absurdity and has cost the Wolfpack at least one game if not more in the past.

In past years, State (TA McLendon in particular) was flagged for excessive celebration penalties that were next to nothing. In other situations, Wolfpackers have taken dives into the end zone with defenders in pursuit and have been called for penalties while other players throughout the country have made similar moves with no flags. State players need to be told that they are under a tighter microscope than most and therefore need to act accordingly. In the meantime, we’d love to see some consistency of the application of these judgement calls by the zebras throughout the country.

Again — we’d love to feature any pics or videos of others’ celebrations.

About StateFans

'StateFansNation' is the shared profile used by any/all of the dozen or so authors that contribute to the blog. You may not always agree with us, but you will have little doubt about where we stand on most issues. Please follow us on Twitter and FaceBook

General Headscratchers NCS Football

17 Responses to Excessive Celebrations – WTF?!

  1. cfpack03 09/25/2006 at 9:37 AM #

    I thought they called our penalty on Andre Brown entering the field w/o a helmet. You can see the ref look directly at #24 and throw the flag. Sorry, couldn’t find the video though

  2. choppack1 09/25/2006 at 9:50 AM #

    cf – was this for the Akron game? and was he on the field?

  3. Trout 09/25/2006 at 9:53 AM #

    I thought it was for Andre Brown entering w/o a helmet as well.

  4. Dan 09/25/2006 at 9:57 AM #

    Maybe the NC State penalty created a memo to not let that happen again at end game situations.

    Anyone see Chuck closeline the kid after the Dunlap catch? He was not going to allow anyone on that field.

  5. RickJ 09/25/2006 at 9:58 AM #

    I found the decision to review Dunlap’s catch somewhat appalling after Tommy Hunt’s explanation of the review process by ACC officials after the Akron game.

    This issue came up in Amato’s press conference on Sunday. He was asked why this play was reviewed and not the one in the Akron game. His answer was a classic:

    “Why would they review it? Because we’re NC State.”

    I can’t say for sure that Michigan State or Colorado would have been flagged if the situations were reversed but I am pretty sure the probability would be a lot higher.

  6. cfpack03 09/25/2006 at 10:16 AM #

    yes, I was referring to the Akron game. Regardless, I do agree that there should be some consistency in the calls, with accountability assigned to the players, coaches, refs, and heads of officiating

  7. choppack1 09/25/2006 at 10:18 AM #

    Thanks for the clarification CF.

    As for Amato’s comment – I couldn’t agree more. The decision not to review the run – or at least announcing they were reviewing it – is still appalling.

  8. Texpack 09/25/2006 at 10:51 AM #

    The reason given by the ESPNU announcers for the Akron penalty was that players left the bench to join the celebration.

  9. noah 09/25/2006 at 10:52 AM #

    If we’re going to have this dumb f-ing penalty, the definition of “excessive celebration” ought to be confined to the pre-planned, pre-scripted, choreographed types of celebrations.

    Frankly, I don’t see what’s wrong with a team reacting with tremendous enthusiasm to a critical score. You score the winning touchdown and the whole team jumps on you in the endzone. That’s a great moment for the fans and for the TV audience.

    I’m not talking about dunking the goalposts or any of T.O’s crap. No White Shoes Johnson moments or Steve Smith’s stuff.

    I’m just talking about jumping up and down with joy as you score at a critical moment.

    Exactly what the f**k is the matter with that??

  10. LSUTigerFan 09/25/2006 at 11:28 AM #

    Why does each conference need there own officials? How about some consistency. I realize the NCAA generally can’t do anything right, but why not give them a shot at a national pool of officials who apply consistent criteria to the games? It should also make the refs better as they would see more coaches, schemes, and players than they do focussing on one conference.

    It would also lessen the likelihood of conference bias and perhaps lessen home team bias since an official would be unlikely to call a game for the same team in the same stadium in the same season.

  11. RAWFS 09/25/2006 at 11:30 AM #

    It’s high time that people took notice generally just how bad college officials are these days – in football or basketball, it doesn’t matter.

    I’d swear that the team of Stevie Wonder, Helen Keller and Ray Charles would be a better job of getting the charge/block or the excessive celebration penalties correct than do the zebras that we have now.

    It’s not just NC State. People call it whining, but Oklahoma’s fans have a legit beef. So do any number of schools so far in this young season.

  12. Cardiff Giant 09/25/2006 at 12:15 PM #

    I agree with Amato’s comment. And I rarely agree with these press conference gems. Tommy Hunt is either biased or cataclysmically retarded.

    As for the EC penalty, I also agree. The inconsistency is complete bullshit.

  13. Pack Laddie 09/25/2006 at 12:51 PM #

    I think there needs to be some leeway given in the excessive celebration penalties. It is a judgment call, and the refs have to have a feel for the situation, and the relative timing and importance of the score. I know the rule is in place for a reason, but let the kids enjoy the moment as long as they are not showing up the other team.

    That being said, the penalty in the Akron game was definitely on Brown for running onto the field without his helmet on. That is not a judgment call, and is an automatic penalty. He knows better, I am sure.

  14. DRW 09/25/2006 at 2:06 PM #

    rawfs: I was talking about the same thing with my brother over the weekend. ‘National’ officials would make things a lot better. Which is probably why it won’t happen.

  15. StateFans 09/25/2006 at 3:41 PM #

    Fair points about the Brown penalty.

  16. WolfpackSteelerfan 09/25/2006 at 4:06 PM #

    I was talking to someone about that after the Akron game as well. They should at least have a rule that you can’t officiate against your arch-rivals. And the fact that a UNC grad is the head of ACC officiating (not to mention the ACC commissioner), is agregious (SP?) in my opinion. Those positions should be filled by someone who graduated from a school outside of the conference, to eliminate any biases. And, there are obvious biases.

    I still can’t understand why NCSU admin was stupid enough to hire Todd Turner as AD.

  17. crackdog 09/26/2006 at 8:36 PM #

    There’s an interesting take on officiating at Mark Cuban’s blog; http://www.blogmaverick.com/2006/09/26/suspending-officials-a-business-lesson/

Leave a Reply