Lip Service Or Getting Tough? NCAA Watching Hoops Recruiting More Closely

Already Committed to Maryland?

Already Committed to Maryland?

In the multi-billion dollar business that is college basketball, high stakes games are played between college programs looking for success, players looking to play their way into the NBA gold mine, and hangers-on looking to latch onto the next big thing so that they too can line their pockets.   Thing is, few fans are truly aware of the way the process works from the inside — they know what they read in the papers or perhaps on blogs like this or message boards devoted to their favorite team, but all of that information is coming from outside the process, and undoubtedly, reporters, boosters and fans are not invited to the backroom dealings that go on every day and often decide where kids are going to play college hoops.

A Tampa Bay Online article, “Recruiting In The Shadows”, gives a good rundown of some recent happenings in hoops recruiting, including a brief John Wall mention:

Last summer, Baylor University hired Dwon Clifton, coach of the AAU team that includes the nation’s top point guard prospect, John Wall from Raleigh, N.C. Wall hasn’t signed a scholarship, but Baylor is on his short list.

No news there for State fans, but as part of a long list of coaches who employ the tactic (including NC State’s former head coach, Herb Sendek) one starts to get a glimpse of the unsavory nature of it all — and that has drawn the attention of the NCAA itself:

“Follow the money, follow the money,” former University of Pennsylvania and Boston College coach Chuck Daly said, evoking images of Hal Holbrook’s stern advice to Robert Redford in “All the President’s Men.”

In an unprecedented move, enforcement officials were deployed to Las Vegas, Orlando and other summer-basketball sites to infiltrate what NCAA President Myles Brand describes as a “dysfunctional” system of recruiting. On a staff of 20 investigators, the NCAA has now designated three solely for men’s basketball.

“There has been growing concern at some of the things developing in men’s basketball,” NCAA spokeswoman Stacey Osburn said. “We want to get deeper into that environment and culture.”

Front and center: The connections between Amateur Athletic Union coaches, sometimes affiliated with agents, and high-profile players.

“Recruiting is extremely difficult right now,” said Virginia Tech coach Seth Greenberg, formerly of USF. “The player is the center of the universe. You’ve got to draw a circle around that player and then touch everyone in that circle. If you don’t touch the right person, you’re going to be eliminated.”

One has to wonder if the NCAA means what it says – that it’s going to get a grip on the situation – or if it is simply another case of Myles Brand giving lip service to restoring integrity to the recruiting game while he cashes CBS’s billion dollar checks for its annual NCAA tournament coverage.  One would be tempted to think the latter will be the case — Brand himself earns at least $895K/year and common sense says that he nor anyone else is going to slaughter the golden goose that’s making everyone involved wealthy.

As to these AAU tournaments:

Talent wins games, so coaches recruit talent. Therefore, head coaches hire assistants who can recruit talent, not develop it. Plenty of Division I coaches cannot teach the game, but they can recruit. Because the NCAA limits off-season practice time and players jump to the NBA after one or two seasons, recruiting is the single greatest element of college basketball.

The best players suffer the same Entitlement Affliction, as they have been The Man at every level. While they may be great with the ball in their hands, they lack the wherewithal to play a team game within a coach’s system. Players stand and watch without the ball and lack the feel for the game; they need set plays to tell them how to move and where to go. They reach, lunge for steals and do not understand help defense and defensive rotations, as they always excelled due to natural ability, size, speed or strength, which evens out at the college level.

College recruiting spawns the year-round AAU play, as it’s more convenient for college coaches to attend 2-3 tournaments each with 40-50 teams filled with legitimate college prospects than to attend high school basketball games and tournaments during their season.

In short, it is a clearinghouse or a cattle-call for talent, depending on what you want to call it.  And now the NCAA is on the case.  Just keep in mind that this is an organization that has gone from banning post-season play for schools giving a ride to a recruit home from a university to one that is perfectly willing to overlook O.J. Mayo and Reggie Bush’s obvious payola just because it would negatively impact one of their big-market high profile teams and thus hurt their own bottom line.

One thing here is good news for NC State and its fans: there has not been a hint of impropriety of any kind by Sidney Lowe and his staff.

Basketball Recruiting

11 Responses to Lip Service Or Getting Tough? NCAA Watching Hoops Recruiting More Closely

  1. Noah 12/16/2008 at 10:14 AM #

    Part of the problem is that the NCAA has no authority over AAU play. They have no authority to tell a street agent that they can’t give $100 to a seventh grader.

    If you are a street agent, you troll around where young, talented players congregate. You pick out the ones that impress you. Get yourself a copy of Rolling Stone and look in the back. There used to be a constant ad…for $25, you could become an ordained minister.

    So, now you’re the Rev. John Niceguy.

    You’ve got your title and you’ve got your marks. Start working them. Son, you’ve got a nice game. I like the way everyone responds to you. Kobe was the same way at your age.

    Don’t just give them a $100 bill. Start working mom. Make sure the light bill is paid and make sure there are some groceries in the house. Make sure that the day before the phone gets turned off, you come through with a payment. Make sure there is a present under the tree for his little sister.

    Maybe none of your flock turns out to be anything. The odds are overwhelming that they won’t. But maybe someone in that NEXT group will be something and the older kids…the one from your original flock will help you out.

    Pretty small investments soon end paying very large dividends. Ask Joel Hopkins.

  2. LKNpackfan 12/16/2008 at 11:15 AM #

    Without question, the NBA’s “Lebron” rule is a giant fan on the recruiting game stink. There are now draft-worthy players who can’t enter the draft until a year after HS graduation, and coachs are doing everything, legal and illegal, to get that kid to choose their program.

    One interesting note to keep an eye on is the Brandon Jennings experiment, aka, lottery-picks going to europe to play for a year instead of going to college. Seems to me like an great decision: hone your skills against better competition, live in europe for a year, and get paid huge sums of money earlier and legally.

  3. Alpha Wolf 12/16/2008 at 11:23 AM #

    ^ Jennings is not gdoing very well in Europe, as I remember.

    Here’s a link:

    http://washingtontimes.com/news/2008/dec/04/first-could-be-the-last/

  4. LKNpackfan 12/16/2008 at 12:18 PM #

    ^Fantastic article. That’s the update I was looking for.

  5. SEAT.5.F.2 12/16/2008 at 1:08 PM #

    What if…

    Just kind of a spectics point of view, but what if the NCAA directs a finger of all that is “shadowy” in recruiting at the little guy (sound familiar yet?) and accomplishes it’s goal of providing a buffer between Shoe companies and the morals/ethic’s rhetoric.

    It would take one naive individual to think that a Shoe company would stop short of anything and everything possible to ensure certain recognizable teams which have coaches that are on company pay roll by contract get what they need to suceed.

  6. Rick 12/16/2008 at 1:44 PM #

    AAU is horrible for basketball.
    The coaching stinks. The players all play one on one and the atmosphere is poison.

  7. Alpha Wolf 12/16/2008 at 1:53 PM #

    ^ AAU is a showcase league, and the emphasis is on players not teams.

    One of my friends here at work called it a hoops singles bar, except he used “meet market.”

  8. Noah 12/16/2008 at 2:09 PM #

    Just kind of a spectics point of view, but what if the NCAA directs a finger of all that is “shadowy” in recruiting at the little guy (sound familiar yet?) and accomplishes it’s goal of providing a buffer between Shoe companies and the morals/ethic’s rhetoric.

    They would run the risk of getting sued. If you are an AAU coach or player, the NCAA doesn’t have anything to do with you or any jurisdiction over you. Just like they don’t if you’re an NAIA player. Those are not NCAA-sanctioned events.

    The NBA would be very smart to adopt baseball’s rules on drafting. Stop making people “declare” for the NBA. You can get drafted out of three windows: HS Senior, college junior, college senior. If you like where you get picked, go sign. If you don’t, go to college.

    People like LeBron James don’t have any business in college. But there are several dozen players every year that don’t have any business in the NBA. The current rules just burn through the only commodity that the NBA has.

  9. Alpha Wolf 12/16/2008 at 2:21 PM #

    ^ That makes a lot of sense to me. Too much sense, actually, and that’s why they will never do it. Surely David Stern has heard of this before.

  10. Noah 12/16/2008 at 4:55 PM #

    Baseball has the added advantage of players telling both colleges and pro teams where their cutoff line is.

    If they’re looking at being picked in the top five rounds, they’ll sign. If not, they’ll go to college. Pro teams can maybe take a flier on them in the 20th round, just in case something happens. College teams can sign a guy and hope for the best, but prepare for the worst.

  11. wufpup76 12/16/2008 at 6:41 PM #

    ““There has been growing concern at some of the things developing in men’s basketball,” NCAA spokeswoman Stacey Osburn said. “We want to get deeper into that environment and culture.”

    ^Nothing like the NCAA being proactive …

    “Front and center: The connections between Amateur Athletic Union coaches, sometimes affiliated with agents, and high-profile players.”

    ^Really? Shocking … welcome to the party.

    “AAU is horrible for basketball.
    The coaching stinks. The players all play one on one and the atmosphere is poison.”

    ^Agreed – 100% … Hate it. It’s David Stern’s nirvana … Emphasize individual play and skills over team play and defense … Thanks, David

    Be careful, though Rick … I’ve criticized AAU on here before and gotten blasted

Leave a Reply